Cheese Store

Our cheese selection changes with the seasons. Spring blows in with raw milk cheeses from the mountains, flavored by the grasses the cows eat. Summer is the time for picnics and fruit and cheese plates, fall means beautiful big wheels of Lincolnshire Poacher and cheddars from Neal’s Yard in England, and winter means the King of Blues, Stilton, with a glass of port by the fire. Our cheeses include sheep, goat, and cow from the plains of Colorado and the hills of California; Italy, England, France, Holland and more, all kept alive in our cheese cave. We make Mozzarella twice a day to keep it fresh.

Belletoile Brie

Pasteurized cow’s milk
This triple cream brie from France is an amazing value & real crowd pleaser!
A Creamy, Dreamy Value!
$9.99 per pound

Haystack Mountain Goat Dairy

Chevre Logs
Pasturized goat's milk
Choose from plain, herbes de Provence, or cracked pepper.
ONLY $4.67 each

Haystack Marinated Chevre
Pasturized goat's milk
$8.99 each

Haystack Queso de Mano
Unpasturized goat's milk
Beautiful raw milk goat cheese aged to perfection.
$23.99 per pound

Haystack Heartland Gouda
Pasturized goat's milk
Made with Goat’s milk from their new farm in Oklahoma by Colorado’s Best known Cheesemakers!
$10.99 per pound

Haystack Mountain Buttercup
Pasteurized cow & goat milks
Made in Niwot from both cow’s & goat’s milk
$16.99 per pound

MouCo Cheese Co. Colorouge or Camembert

Pasturized cow's milk
ONLY $7.99 each

Prima Donna

Pasturized cow's milk
Aged gouda from Holland with nutty, caramelly flavors & salt crystals to make your mouth water. Our best seller.
If you don’t love this, you don’t like cheese
$12.99 per pound

Membrillo Quince Paste from Spain

Classic accompaniment to Manchego or any other cheese.
Sweet & tangy
$10.99 per pound

St. Jorge

The Matos Family dairy in Santa Rosa, California is owned by a 5th generation cheesemaker from the island of São Jorge, off the coast of Portugal.
Marczyk Fine Foods EXCLUSIVE!
$16.99 per pound

Vella Cheese Company Mezzo Secco.

Pasturized cow's milk
A medium dry jack from Sonoma, California
$13.99 per pound

Point Reyes Original Blue.

Unpasturized cow's milk
Eat this with Niman Ranch Steaks!
When you stand on the hilltop at Bill Niman’s ranch in California, look across the valley & you will see the Giacomini Ranch where this cheese is made…They are perfect together!
$16.99 per pound

Epoisses

Pasteurized cow’s milk
A Fall Classic from Burgundy
This beautiful cheese is washed with brandy, so creamy & rich!
Try it with a Pinot Noir from our Wine Shop
$17.99 per pound

Rogue Creamery Smokey Blue

Unpasteurized cow’s milk
Smoked over Hazelnut Shells
Maybe the best cheese we have. Try this with an Oregon Pinot Noir from our Wineshop!
$19.99 per pound

Roquefort

Unpasteurized sheep’s milk
Quintessential… Timeless… Blue
From the Cambalou Caves of Southern France.
$29.99 per pound

Parmigiano Reggiano

Unpasturized cow's milk
The World’s Greatest Cheese!
Aged 24 months. You’ll never go back to the green can!
$19.99 per pound

Piave del Vecchio

Pasteurized cow’s milk
Shaved over a salad of arugula, bresaola & truffle oil with a bottle of Chianti
$17.99 per pound

Pierre Robert

Pasteurized cow’s milk
The most decadent triple crème you’ll find
$21.99 per pound

Le Chatelain Camembert

Pasteurized cow’s milk
A Normandy Classique!
Beautiful with apples and fresh baguette
$7.99 per pound

Gerôme Munster

Pasteurized cow’s milk
Alsace at its Best
Try melting this over roasted fingerling potatoes & leeks, served with our Market Made Toulouse sausage and a bottle of Reisling
$12.99 each

Cypress Grove Humboldt Fog

Unpasteurized goat’s milk
Morning milk and evening milk separated by beautiful charcoal ash, made lovingly by Mary Keehn in Humboldt County, California.
$20.99 per pound

Robiola Duo Latte

Pasteurized sheep & cow’s milk
Soft and sleek.
$10.99 each

Taleggio

Pasteurized cow’s milk
Tastes how a great bakery smells…
This washed rind brick from Lombardy has been touted as the most refined & sophisticated of all the Italian cheeses
$14.99 per pound

Gorgonzola Dolce

Pasteurized cow’s milk
Super Creamy Italian Blue
$14.99 per pound

Canadian Cheddar

Pasteurized cow’s milk
2 year aged sharp White Cheddar
AWESOME Value!
$9.99 per pound

Gruyere

Unpasteurized cow’s milk
The CLASSIC Swiss cheese
Aged 18 months, nutty, creamy & delicious
$15.99 per pound

Emmenthaler

Pasteurized cow’s milk
Fondue anyone?
$9.99 per pound

Pecorino Tartufello

Pasteurized sheep’s milk
Shave this onto your next omelette, beautiful with black & white truffles. Luxe!
$21.99 per pound

Pecorino Toscano

Unpasteurized sheep’s milk
Tuscany’s Pride
Aged 18 months, nutty, sweet, & salty
$15.99 per pound

Asiago Fresca

Pasteurized cow’s milk
Melts well, & is great in grilled cheese sandwiches!
$13.99 per pound

Manchego

Unpasteurized sheep’s milk
Serve this with shaved Jamon Serrano, Arbequina olives, membrillo & Marcona Almonds alongside a great bottle of Tempranillo!
$18.99 per pound

Fromager d’Affinois

Pasteurized cow’s milk
Silky and creamy double cream brie.
$8.99 per pound

Saint Agur

Pasteurized cow’s milk
Creamy, earthy blue
Beautiful, rich blue cheese from the Jura mountains in France.
$19.99 per pound

Fontina Val D’Aosta

Unpasteurized cow’s milk
This Piedmontese Classic is so beautiful in the Fall!
Pairs nicely with apples & pears, or try adding it to a mushroom risotto – delicious!
$14.99 per pound

Buche du Poitou

Pasteurized goat’s milk
Fancy French Goat cheese for everyday!
Great crumbled on a salad or served with fresh bread & white wine!
$16.99 per pound

Marcona Almonds

Spain
Roasted and salted
$19.99 per pound

P’tit Basque

Pasteurized sheep’s milk
Mild, sweet, and nutty
$19.99 per pound

Abbaye de Bellocq

Unpasteurized sheep’s milk
Rich, sweet flavor of caramelized sugar.
$23.99 per pound

Raclette

Unpasteurized cow’s milk
The world’s most famous melting cheese.
$10.99 per pound

Morbier

Unpasteurized cow’s milk
Complex, fruity flavor with a slight tang.
$13.99 per pound

Murcia al Vino

Pasteurized goat milk
Wine cured goat cheese made from the best goat milk in all of Spain. Serve, appropriately, with a full-bodied Spanish red.
$15.99 per pound

Grana Padano Parmesan

Unpasteurized cow milk
Shredded
$12.99 per pound

Tipperary Cheddar

Pasteurized cow’s milk
IRISH CHEDDAR!
Creamy, Sharp & Melts like a Dream!
$10.99 per pound

Neal’s Yard Dairy Cashel Blue

Pasteurized cow’s milk
Earthy, Creamy & Mushroomy!
$15.99 per pound

Chimay a la Biere

Pasteurized cow’s milk
Washed with Chimay beer by Monks!
Delicious, creamy, & versatile!
$13.99 per pound

Le Roule

Pasteurized cow’s milk
Rolled with Garlic & Herbs
Creamy & Yummy, Try some today!
$12.99 per pound

James Ranch

James Ranch Leyden
Unpasteurized cow’s milk
With Cumin Seeds
Made in Durango from pasture-fed, Jersey cow’s milk on the family owned James Ranch
$22.99 per pound

James Ranch Belford
Unpasteurized cow’s milk
Made in Durango from pasture-fed, Jersey cow’s milk on the family owned James Ranch.
$22.99 per pound

Three Sisters Farmstead Cheese, Serena

Pasteurized cow’s milk
Sharp, with a sweet tang
Produced by one the youngest cheesemakers in the U.S. on a 3rd generation dairy farm in California’s Central Valley. ACS award winner!
$14.99 per pound

Bravo Farms Chipotle Cheddar

Unpasteurized cow’s milk
Smoky & Spicy!
Smoked Jalapenos give this artisan cheddar from California the perfect kick!
$10.99 per pound

Fiscalini Farms Cheddar

Unpasteurized cow’s milk
Bandage wrapped & aged for two-year
Traditional Farmstead Cheddar from California
$19.99 per pound

Roomano

Unpasteurized cow’s milk
Super Aged Gouda
Nutty, Sharp, and Salty. This cheese and a good beer are best friends.
$19.99 per pound

L’edel de Cleron

Pasteurized cow’s milk
Perfumed with scents of the forest, this Franche-Comte is rich & creamy and an absolute must-have.
$14.99 per pound

Brescianella

Pasteurized cow’s milk
Washed-rind, soft-ripened cheese from Lombardy. Smooth with rich flavors and a lingering, grassy aftertaste.
$14.99 per pound